
In November 1924, a hand-lettered sign went up in the town of Bishop, California: “If I am not on the JOB, You can find me at the AQUEDUCT.”
The aqueduct belonged to the City of Los Angeles, more than two hundred miles to the south. The water inside it had once irrigated the orchards and pastures of the Owens Valley. Beginning in 1905, Los Angeles bought valley land, and the water rights that came with it. The aqueduct opened in 1913. In 1923 the city started buying again, farther up the valley. As the city pumped, the water table fell, and farms next to city-owned land dried out. Neighbors sold. The ones who stayed watched their ditches go dry.
On 16 November 1924, ranchers from around Bishop drove south to the Alabama Gates, a spillway on the aqueduct north of Lone Pine. They took the gatehouse and opened the gates. The city’s water left its concrete channel and poured into the dry bed of the Owens River. Townspeople closed their shops and followed, and the crowd grew to about seven hundred. Families cooked meals beside the canal. The story ran in newspapers across the country and overseas. Governor Friend Richardson asked the state engineer, W. F. McClure, to investigate the dispute. On 20 November, the occupiers held a barbecue, closed the gates, and went home.
The publicity was enormous. The result was close to nothing. Los Angeles kept buying land. In August 1927 the valley’s banks, owned by the resistance leaders Mark and Wilfred Watterson, collapsed over embezzlement, and the brothers went to San Quentin. With them went the fight.
For four days the valley held the gates. It never held a seat at the table where the rules were written.
The new aqueducts
A data center is a warehouse full of computers. It runs the cloud services we use every day and, increasingly, the artificial intelligence (AI) systems everyone is talking about. Those computers draw enormous amounts of electricity, and many facilities use large volumes of water to keep them cool. Like the aqueduct, a data center draws resources from one place to serve demand somewhere else.
So the Owens Valley questions are back. Who decides where these buildings go? Who pays for the power lines and water they need? Who gets the benefit, and who gets the bill?
Europe and the United States answer those questions differently. A popular shorthand says Europe protects people while America protects profits. That slogan is too simple. Both systems balance competing goods, and some American states now set tougher rules than parts of Europe. The real difference lies in how the rules are built. The European Union (EU) sets a shared framework, and each member country adds its own requirements on top. In the United States, the rules depend on where a project lands: federal agencies, state legislatures, county boards, and utility regulators all hold a piece. Neither system is uniform.
What Europe asks of a data center
Europe’s first guardrail is disclosure. Under the EU’s Energy Efficiency Directive (Directive (EU) 2023/1791), the owner or operator of any data center with at least 500 kilowatts of computing equipment must report every year to a common EU database. That threshold is modest. The largest AI campuses draw hundreds of times more.
A follow-up rule, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2024/1364, adopted on 14 March 2024, spells out what operators must report: energy use, water use, the reuse of waste heat, and whether the facility helps stabilize the grid. One key measure is power usage effectiveness (PUE). Think of it as overhead. A PUE of 1.0 would mean every watt goes to the computers. A PUE of 1.5 means that for every two watts the computers use, another watt goes to cooling, lighting, and everything else.
An important correction belongs here. Reporting is not a performance mandate. EU law does not yet require every data center to hit the same efficiency target. It requires every covered facility to show its numbers, and it leaves penalties to each country.
Some countries go much further. Germany’s Energy Efficiency Act of 2023 requires new data centers that open on or after 1 July 2026 to reach a PUE of 1.2 within two years. Older facilities must reach 1.5 by 1 July 2027 and 1.3 by 1 July 2030. German operators have had to cover half their electricity with renewable power since 2024, rising to all of it from 1 January 2027, counted on an annual balance-sheet basis. New sites must also reuse a share of their waste heat, often to warm nearby homes and offices: at least 10 percent for facilities opening from July 2026, rising to 20 percent for those opening from July 2028. The industry has pushed back hard, and as of early November 2026, a government bill to delay the full renewable requirement to 2030 and loosen some efficiency limits was still pending in the Bundestag.
Europe wants more data centers, too
It would be a mistake to picture Europe as simply saying no. On 3 June 2026, the European Commission proposed the Cloud and AI Development Act (CADA). Its stated goal is to triple Europe’s data center capacity within five to seven years. Each member country would have to designate at least one acceleration zone, where permits must be decided within twelve months, with a preference for previously developed land and sites with grid capacity. The proposal also creates a sovereignty framework that steers public agencies toward cloud services under European control, because Europe worries about depending on American and Chinese providers for its most sensitive data. CADA is still a proposal. The European Parliament and the member governments must agree before it becomes law.
That is how Europe tries to balance grid capacity, sustainability, and digital sovereignty: build more, build where the grid and the land can bear it, and prove the efficiency on paper. The balance is hard, and two countries show the strain.
In Ireland, data centers account for close to half of electricity demand in the Dublin and Meath region. For several years, the grid operator effectively stopped connecting new ones around Dublin. On 12 December 2025, Ireland’s Commission for Regulation of Utilities (CRU) set the terms for reopening: new data centers must bring their own power plants or batteries, on site or nearby, to match their demand. In the Netherlands, the municipalities of Amsterdam and Haarlemmermeer halted new data center permits on 12 July 2019 while they wrote rules for land and power. In 2022, Meta paused a giant campus planned for Zeewolde after the Dutch Senate voted to reconsider it.
European public opinion supports the environmental goals behind these guardrails. In the EU’s Special Eurobarometer 565, carried out between 18 February and 10 March 2025 and published on 30 June 2025, 85 percent of respondents called climate change a serious problem and 81 percent supported the goal of climate neutrality by 2050. Support for a goal is not support for every restriction, though, and Europeans also want jobs, investment, and technological independence.
America’s patchwork
Washington has chosen speed. On 23 July 2025, Executive Order 14318, “Accelerating Federal Permitting of Data Center Infrastructure,” directed federal agencies to fast-track environmental reviews for large projects, roughly those costing more than $500 million or adding more than 100 megawatts of demand, and to offer federal land and financial support. It did not repeal federal environmental law, and it cannot override state and local approvals. Zoning, water permits, and utility hookups still happen close to home.
Close to home is where the real American guardrails are being built, and rebuilt.
Tax breaks. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL), 38 states offer dedicated tax incentives to data centers. In 2026, lawmakers in 28 of those states introduced bills to change them, and at least nine considered repealing them outright. A 2025 Good Jobs First study found that most states with these subsidies do not disclose which companies receive them.
Water. No federal rule limits how much water a data center may use. Instead, NCSL counted about 100 bills and resolutions in 39 states addressing data center water use in 2025 and 2026. Utah now requires large new facilities to consult their water providers before construction and to report water use every year. California requires a water supply assessment before local governments approve new or expanded facilities.
Electric bills. When a utility builds new power plants and lines for a data center, ordinary customers can end up sharing the cost. The fix is a large-load tariff, a separate rate class that makes the biggest users pay for what they require. As of September 2026, the Edison Electric Institute (EEI) counted 25 states with at least one approved. Oklahoma and South Dakota wrote such protections into law in 2026. On 16 September 2026, the US House passed the Ratepayer Protection Act, 417 to 3. It would require state regulators to consider making large data centers pay the full cost of the grid upgrades built for them. It now sits in the Senate, where critics call it largely voluntary.
Pauses. On 14 July 2026, New York Governor Kathy Hochul signed Executive Order 62, a statewide moratorium of up to one year on new data centers of 50 megawatts or more, while state agencies write rules on energy, water, ratepayers, and community benefits. By then more than 100 American towns and counties had adopted or considered local moratoriums of their own.
Shareholders, stakeholders, and the human person
Some readers frame the American fight as stakeholder capitalism against the deeper concerns of humanity. The terms need sorting first. The classic contest sets shareholder capitalism against stakeholder capitalism. Milton Friedman stated the first in “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits,” published in The New York Times Magazine on 13 September 1970. The second gained a famous American endorsement on 19 August 2019, when 181 chief executives signed the Business Roundtable statement promising to serve customers, workers, suppliers, and communities as well as shareholders.
The drivers on the American side are real, and the strongest case for speed deserves a fair hearing. Its defenders argue that computing capacity is now national infrastructure, tied to economic leadership and national security in a race with China. Capacity that is not built here will be built somewhere else, often on dirtier grids with less oversight. Data centers bring construction jobs and large property tax payments while asking little of local schools and services. And Europe itself proves the point: after years of caution, the Commission now wants to triple capacity, and the Amsterdam region lost investment it may never recover.
That case is serious. It still misses the question the Owens Valley asked. Speed versus caution is not the deepest divide. The deepest divide runs between promises and rules. Stakeholder capitalism, practiced as a corporate pledge, is voluntary. The White House Ratepayer Protection Pledge of March 2026, in which major technology companies promised to pay their fair share, carries no enforcement. A large-load tariff does. So does Oklahoma’s law, and New York’s pause. The United States is not choosing between greed and humanity. Its states and towns are deciding, one hearing at a time, whether the people who carry the burdens get a vote.
Measured against People, Planet, Purpose, and Prosperity for everyone, Europe’s stated values score well, and its law scores more modestly.
People. The EU’s Declaration on Digital Rights and Principles puts people, inclusion, and participation at the center. It is a political commitment, not an enforceable guarantee.
Planet. Energy, water, renewable power, and waste heat are written into actual reporting rules, and in Germany into performance standards.
Purpose. The EU says digital technology should improve lives. No law asks whether any particular data center’s work serves society.
Prosperity for everyone. Here both continents fall short. Neither framework settles who owns the infrastructure, who keeps the profits, who pays the higher bills, or who gets to use the computing power. A data center can be efficient and still unfair.
Five questions for the next public hearing
When a data center comes to your county, these questions cut through the brochures:
Who pays? Does the developer cover the new power, water, and grid costs it creates, or do households and small businesses share them?
What are the local limits? Has anyone studied water supply, grid reliability, noise, and air quality before the vote?
What can residents know? Are energy and water figures, tax breaks, and company commitments public and written in plain language?
What does the community receive? Are the promised jobs, tax revenue, and training specific, counted, and checked?
Who can enforce the promises? Are there monitoring, penalties, and a way to claw back subsidies if commitments go unmet?
The best guardrails ask more than whether a data center can run efficiently. They ask whether the public gains outweigh the private ones, and whether the people who carry the burdens have a real voice in the decision.
The Alabama Gates still stand beside US Highway 395, north of Lone Pine. A historical marker tells travelers what happened there. The ranchers opened the gates by hand, and for four days the Owens River had water again. Then the gates closed, because nothing on paper said they had to stay open.
The towns facing data centers today do not need to seize anything. They need the paper.
This time, get it in writing.
Sources. Center for the Study of Los Angeles Research Collection, Loyola Marymount University, J. D. Black Papers, photographs of the Alabama Gates occupation, 16–20 November 1924. W. F. McClure, Letter of Transmittal and Report of W. F. McClure, State Engineer, concerning the Owens Valley–Los Angeles Controversy, to Governor Friend Wm. Richardson, via Calisphere. EBSCO Research Starters, “Farmers Dynamite Los Angeles Aqueduct.” Directive (EU) 2023/1791 (Energy Efficiency Directive), Article 12. Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2024/1364 of 14 March 2024. Germany, Energy Efficiency Act (Energieeffizienzgesetz, 2023), sections 11–12, summarized by White & Case and Linklaters. European Commission, “Proposal for the Cloud and AI Development Act (CADA),” COM(2026) 502, 3 June 2026. Commission for Regulation of Utilities, Large Energy Users Connection Policy Decision Paper, 12 December 2025. Data Center Dynamics, “The Ongoing Impact of Amsterdam’s Data Center Moratorium.” European Commission, Special Eurobarometer 565, “Climate Change,” 30 June 2025. European Declaration on Digital Rights and Principles (2022). Executive Order 14318, “Accelerating Federal Permitting of Data Center Infrastructure,” 23 July 2025, 90 Fed. Reg. 35385. NCSL, “Subsidizing Servers: How States Are Competing to Attract Data Centers,” April 2026. NCSL, “As They Consider New Data Centers, States Target Water Use,” 8 October 2026. Stateline, “Most States Don’t Disclose Which Companies Get Data Center Incentives,” 12 November 2025. Edison Electric Institute, statement on the Ratepayer Protection Act, 15 September 2026. Akin Gump, “House Passes Ratepayer Protection Act,” 16 September 2026. Jones Day, “New York Enacts First Statewide Data Center Moratorium,” July 2026. Milton Friedman, “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits,” The New York Times Magazine, 13 September 1970. Business Roundtable, Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation, 19 August 2019.

