In the last year of the Second World War, a police sergeant from the Rai Coast of New Guinea walked the streets of Brisbane, trying to make sense of what he saw.
He could not read, and his English was poor. He had stayed loyal to the Australians when the Japanese invaded, fought against them in 1942, and in 1944 survived an ambush on a coast-watching mission near Hollandia. He escaped on foot and walked about 120 miles over roughly three months to reach Allied lines at Aitape.
Now the army had brought him south. He saw the wharves, the traffic, a zoo. Then, in the Queensland Museum, he saw something no one had prepared him for. The sacred objects of his own people’s religion sat behind glass, in a white man’s building, in a white man’s city.
He also heard promises. Help win the war, Australian officers told men like him, and economic assistance will follow. He believed them.
His name was Yali Singina, born about 1912 near Sor village. He went home and spoke up and down the coast about cooperation and reward. His listeners heard something else: that Yali had learned the secret. The goods the Europeans enjoyed would come, if the right knowledge were applied. When the reward did not arrive as people expected, many concluded the secret was being kept from them. Yali himself came to believe the missionaries had not told him the whole truth.
Twenty-three years later, on 4 March 1968, a monk in a cinder-block hermitage in Kentucky finished Peter Lawrence’s Road Belong Cargo (Manchester University Press, 1964), a study of the cargo movement in the southern Madang District told largely through Yali’s life. Thomas Merton noted that day that he had “to try to get some of this on paper soon.“
Four years later, in July 1972, Yali put his famous question to a young American biologist named Jared Diamond: why do white people have so much cargo? Diamond spent a career answering with geography, in Guns, Germs, and Steel (W. W. Norton, 1997).
Merton had already answered differently. He turned the question around.
See: Runways in the Jungle
Joseph Cardijn gave the Young Christian Workers (JOC) a three-step discipline: See, Judge, Act. Look at reality as it is before deciding what it means. Weigh it against the Gospel and against what a human being is for. Then do something about it on Monday. Pope John XXIII commended the method to the whole Church in Mater et Magistra (1961). It suits Merton well, because Merton refused to judge anything he had not first looked at hard.
So first, look.
What the islanders did. Anthropologists use “cargo“ for the trade goods that missionaries, planters, traders, and colonial officials carried into Melanesia: tinned meat, steel tools, cloth, motor vehicles. Between first contact and about 1970, observers recorded as many as 200 separate cargo movements. They did not begin with the Second World War. In Madang alone, Lawrence traced five phases running from 1871 to 1950. The war intensified them. Islanders watched aircraft and ships unload more goods in a month than they had seen in a lifetime. In some places, people built airstrips, bamboo control towers, and drill grounds with wooden rifles, expecting the cargo to follow.
What the islanders understood. It is easy to laugh. The best scholars did not. Peter Worsley read the movements as early resistance to economic and political domination. Kenelm Burridge, who did fieldwork in Madang, argued that they were struggles for dignity and equality with the Europeans who ruled them. The islanders had seen the surface of an industrial system whose factories, credit, and supply chains lay out of sight. With the knowledge they had, they reasoned that so much wealth must come from secret ritual knowledge. That was not stupidity. It was a theory, built from the evidence available and from a worldview in which the sacred and the material had never been separated.
What Merton saw in us. Merton read deeply in this literature in his final year. He owned Jean Guiart’s 1952 article on the John Frum movement on Tanna. He finished Lawrence on Yali in March. In August, he corresponded with Archbishop Adolph Noser of Madang, who sent him books on the movements. In 1968, he recorded a talk he called “Cargo Theology.” Edited from that tape, it appeared after his death as “Cargo Cults of the South Pacific” in Love and Living (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1979), edited by Naomi Burton Stone and Brother Patrick Hart.
The essay’s real subject is not Melanesia. It is the West. Consider the promises our own culture makes:
Buy the newest technology, and your life will improve.
Acquire wealth, and you will be secure.
Gain status, and you will matter.
Back the right political ideology, and society will be transformed.
Adopt the latest innovation, and human progress will follow.
Each is a runway. Each assumes that if we perform the right outward actions, meaning will land. Merton borrowed Burridge’s word for the shared story that holds such hopes together, the “myth-dream,” and he insisted that industrial societies dream too. Ours is simply better funded.
He also saw the arrogance underneath. Westerners tend to treat more machines and more goods as proof of moral and spiritual superiority. That belief conveniently forgets the colonial exploitation and racism that carried the cargo to Melanesia in the first place. On 16 January 1968, writing to the civil rights historian Vincent Harding, Merton said he was “very involved in the Cargo Cults and their apocalyptic meaning,“ and that white America looked to him to be up a blind alley and standing under judgment. His interest was not anthropological curiosity. It was solidarity with peoples whose dignity colonial power had wounded, and a warning to the power that wounded them.
Judge: The False Self Is Always Waiting for a Shipment
Judging means asking what the facts mean for the human person. Here Merton’s cargo essay meets the idea that runs through his whole life’s work: the false self.
A self built from cargo. Merton’s false self is the identity we construct out of things that cannot actually tell us who we are. It rests on:
What we own.
What we accomplish.
What other people think of us.
Which political or religious tribe we belong to.
How much influence or power we hold.
The false self scans the horizon for its next load. It whispers that the next purchase, promotion, or experience will finally fill the emptiness. It never does, because the emptiness is not a shortage of goods. For Merton, the true self is not constructed at all. It is received, in silence, in relationship with God. Nothing on the plane can deliver it.
The cargo cult, then, is the false self at the scale of a civilization. A society can surround itself with dazzling machines and still ache inside, and the ache becomes the market for the next machine.
The strongest case on the other side. Fairness requires stating it at full strength. The cargo was real. The planes did land. Antibiotics, clean water, refrigeration, and cheap communication have lengthened and eased billions of lives, and a person who has never lacked them has little standing to call them illusions. Nor was Merton a Luddite. He read Jacques Ellul’s The Technological Society and judged it prophetic, yet too pessimistic. The cargo essay itself survives because a tape recorder caught his voice. Technology serves human dignity every day.
Merton grants all of that. His objection is not to cargo but to the myth that cargo saves. Goods are good. Treating them as salvation is the error, and it makes us blind to whoever pays for the goods. He warned that progress without wisdom could become “an expensive and complicated way of cultural disintegration.“
The newest runway. Now look at artificial intelligence (AI). We are promised more information, greater productivity, better decisions, more efficient institutions, and expanded human capability. Some of that will prove true. Merton would still ask the questions the brochures leave out:
Does more information make us wiser?
Does more powerful technology make us more compassionate?
Does greater efficiency make a society more just?
Does instant communication mean we understand one another?
Are we building technology to serve human dignity, or letting technology decide what a human being is worth?
A recommendation engine is a machine for finding and feeding the false self, better at it than any institution in history. That is not a metaphor. It is a description of the product.
Merton was not chiefly afraid that we would misuse our tools. He feared we would mistake technical advance for human progress. Perhaps the greatest danger of AI is not that machines will become more like us. It is that we will learn to live more like machines.
Act: Stop Waiting on the Runway
Cardijn never let a study circle end with a judgment. It ended with something a person would do that week. Merton’s critique becomes useful only when it changes a decision. Five practices, short enough for an index card:
Name the promise. Before adopting a new tool, write down in one sentence what it promises to give you. Then ask whether that is a good it can deliver, or a meaning it cannot.
Ask who pays. For every system, ask whom it makes larger and at whose expense: people, the planet, purpose, and prosperity for everyone, or only for a few.
Separate efficiency from justice. When an institution adopts AI, ask what it will do with the time and money saved. A faster system that serves the same few is not progress.
Keep one hour that produces nothing. Silence, prayer, a walk without a device. The true self is found where nothing is being acquired, and Merton would say there is nowhere else to look.
Listen to those the cargo passed by. Merton listened to the Melanesians and to Black Americans. Today that means the workers who label training data, the towns that host the data centers, and the people sorted by algorithms they never see.
For a classroom or a lecture, one question carries the whole argument: Are we building our own cargo cults? We have become masters at making the tools that shape a civilization. We have not yet learned to build a civilization that cherishes people. Too often we mistake information for wisdom, wealth for well-being, power for greatness, and new technology for human growth. Merton calls us to shift our gaze from what we can acquire to who we are becoming.
That is the question this site keeps asking. What kind of humans are we becoming?
The Glass Case
Go back to the Queensland Museum. A sergeant who could not read stands in front of a glass case. Inside are the sacred things of his people, collected and labeled by the same civilization that owned the ships, the planes, and the cargo.
He drew the conclusion his world allowed: if the Europeans kept his people’s old gods so carefully, those gods could not be worthless. The power behind the cargo had to be religious.
Merton drew a harder one. The glass case was not only a record of what the West had taken from others. It was a picture of what the West had done to itself. We put the sacred behind glass to make room for the cargo. Then we stood on the runway and waited for meaning to land.
The planes still come, every day, faster than ever.
Merton to Vincent Harding, 16 January 1968, in Witness to Freedom: The Letters of Thomas Merton in Times of Crisis, edited by William H. Shannon (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1994), 242. Thomas Merton Center quotation record.
Merton’s correspondence with Archbishop Adolph Noser, 1968: Thomas Merton Center.
Merton’s cargo cult materials, including Jean Guiart, “John Frum Movement in Tanna,” Oceania 22, no. 3 (March 1952): Thomas Merton Center subject index.
Kenelm Burridge, “Merton, Cargo Cults and The Geography of Lograire,” The Merton Annual 17 (2004): 206–215. PDF.
Peter Lawrence, Road Belong Cargo: A Study of the Cargo Movement in the Southern Madang District, New Guinea (Manchester University Press, 1964).